Goodbye, FitBit–welcome back, BodyMedia

by Mary C. Weaver, CSCS on June 3, 2013

bodymedia link armband
Send to Kindle

For a certain kind of person, gadgets make fitness more fun and the process of getting fit more exciting. Of course, I’m a geek who believes more information (in every area of life) is better.

Maybe everyone is at least a little bit motivated by seeing the data. If not, why would makers of aerobic equipment put calorie counters and heart-rate monitors on elliptical trainers, treadmills, and the like?

Management expert Tom Peters likes to say, “What gets measured gets done.” And research has proven that those who track their progress—whether we’re talking about calorie counting or step counting—do a better job.

Simplest example I can think of: people who wear pedometers take more steps than those who don’t wear them. Does it really matter why?

So today I want to talk about my latest experiment in quantifying my activity level and calorie burn. I’m going to explain why I’ve stopped wearing my new FitBit Zip and returned to my BodyMedia Link armband.

What the FitBit does

FitBit comes in multiple versions, and the one I used is the Zip, the least expensive option (currently $49 on Amazon.com). It’s basically a small, elegant jumped-up pedometer. It tracks steps and distance, yes, but also claims to track calories burned.

Fancier models also track stairs climbed as well as how long and well you sleep.

You can display your activity via smartphone apps and on the fitbit website, which is free to use. And the FitBit’s little display shows you how many steps you’ve taken, what time it is, and how many calories it thinks you’ve burned.

The device does one thing very nicely: track steps.

But its claim to be an “activity monitor” [click to keep reading…]

{ 15 comments }

Is dieting dangerous?

by Mary C. Weaver, CSCS on May 28, 2013

weight loss diet
Send to Kindle

“Diets cause weight gain.”

“Diets cause food obsession and eating disorders.”

“Diets blind you to your body’s intuitive eating signals.”

You can find all kinds of books, articles, and websites that expound on these topics, and I’m not going to waste your time going into detail on their points of view.

I can’t deny that dieting gets a bad rap. And most kinds of dieting thoroughly deserve it.

Hell, a supposed health coach in an online forum told me yesterday that calorie counting was “soul crushing” and “ridiculous.” I suggested that on the contrary, it was merely a tool that can be used well or badly . . . and that if we have a problem with it, maybe we’ve brought along our own baggage.

That wasn’t a popular idea. I was roundly shouted down by those who believe that “intuition” alone ought to be enough to bring about our ideal weight. (Sure, go for it: I feel sorry for your clients, who may waste a couple of years figuring out that it’s usually not enough.)

Dieting is just a tool

Here’s the point: dieting (like its cousin calorie-counting) is just a tool.

There are good tools and very, very bad tools in this toolbox.

But before we get more specific, let’s clarify the term. Let’s see “dieting” for what it is: merely a food plan, a way of eating. In other words, let’s strip away some of the baggage.

I bitch and moan about bad diets all the time, not because I enjoy bitching and moaning (oh, OK—just a little) but because I see the damage bad diets cause women. I bitch and moan about bad diets all the time, not because I enjoy bitching and moaning (oh, OK—just a little) but because I see the damage bad diets cause women.

Every time I offer a free webinar (more on that subject later) I talk about the dangers of bad diets. And while I was writing this, I realized that you, esteemed reader and listener, might assume that I’m speaking only of extreme and obviously crazy diets.

I’ve gone on and on about the dangers of the hCG diet, which is nothing more than slow starvation. I’ve talked about how intermittent fasting can slow your metabolism and screw up your appetite-regulating hormones.

But maybe you’re thinking that the average women’s magazine diet that recommends, say, 1,300 to 1,500 calories a day is surely immune from that sort of criticism.

Not.

Not at ALL.

Dangers of the average bad diet

The average diet—yes, even the average diet that a health expert thinks is swell—often provides too few calories to

  • protect your muscle mass (and although you may think you don’t care about this, darling, you do)
  • prevent undue hunger
  • sustain an effective exercise program and
  • prevent your metabolic rate—the amount of energy you need daily—from slowing down.

Of course, the existence of bad diets hints that perhaps there’s such a thing as a good diet, a safe and healthy diet, doesn’t it?

In fact, there is. That’s one of the things I teach.

We’ve been conditioned to believe that dieting—that is, choosing a food plan specifically for fat loss—has to mean weeks or months of hideous deprivation, hunger, and sacrifice.

It doesn’t. Not if we jettison the notion that makes so many diets dangerous: the idea that cutting more calories is the solution to effective fat loss.

Here’s what you might not realize: You might think cutting 500 calories a day is perfectly reasonable and not the least bit dangerous.

That’s just a pound a week. Sounds sensible, right?

Most diets don’t even consider your individual energy needs

But is a 500-calorie cut per day safe?

That depends on you and your specific energy needs.

  • What’s your total daily need for calories?
  • What percentage of a cut would 500 calories represent for you?
  • Is that percentage too much or too little for you?

How to find out

Interested?

Well, this is one of the topics I’m going to teach during my next free online training session, set for 7 p.m. Eastern time (U.S.) on Wednesday, June 12.

In fact, if you’re live on the webinar with me, I’m going to walk you step by step through an easy, fast, and accurate way to figure out the right number of calories for you to cut.

My goal is to help you understand exactly how to choose the right level of calorie cutting for safe and healthy fat loss . . . so you don’t slow your metabolism, you don’t feel ravenous, and you can actually stick to the plan.

That’s not the only subject I’ll be covering, but I’ll tell you more in my next blog post.

In the meantime, if you’re dieting now or ever will be, you need this training.

I’ll record the session, so if you have a commitment at that time and date, sign up anyway.

But if you can make it live, that’s best. As I said, I’ll be walking you through the process of implementing one of my best fat-loss strategies . . . and everyone live on the webinar with me will receive a valuable gift.

Save your spot now!

{ 0 comments }

Is a brisk walk as good as a run?

May 3, 2013
Thumbnail image for Is a brisk walk as good as a run?

This one’s for the walkers: If you’ve ever felt bad because you can’t jog or just don’t feel like it, I have good news. True, you can’t burn as many calories per minute walking as you can running—but you can get the same health benefits, according to some new research. It’ll just take [...]

Read the full article →

Squeeze more exercise into half the time

March 26, 2013
Thumbnail image for Squeeze more exercise into half the time

Quick—what’s the No. 1 reason you either don’t exercise or don’t log as many workouts as you’d like? Most women I know will say “not enough time!” I say it too. We’re all overscheduled, with so many more commitments than our calendars can hold. But here’s yet another study (among many) suggesting that [...]

Read the full article →

How to turn ‘diet failure’ into weight-loss success

March 25, 2013
Thumbnail image for How to turn ‘diet failure’ into weight-loss success

Send to Kindle“Past performance is no guarantee of future results.” That’s the boilerplate we see when we buy a mutual fund or other potentially risky investment. It serves as a warning, lest we think success is a sure thing. But what if we flipped things around and used those words to encourage ourselves? What if [...]

Read the full article →

Low-carb diet? Why your week 1 weight loss is meaningless

March 21, 2013
Thumbnail image for Low-carb diet? Why your week 1 weight loss is meaningless

Diet gurus love low-carb diets—and dieters love them—because going on one usually causes a dramatic loss of weight the first week. Notice that I didn’t say loss of fat. People get all excited about that first week’s weight loss of four, five, or six pounds or more. Well, there’s an easy explanation for [...]

Read the full article →

Do potatoes make you fat?

March 20, 2013
Thumbnail image for Do potatoes make you fat?

Do potatoes make you fat? Well, they certainly can . . . the same way any food can: if you eat too much of it, you get fat. It’s true of potatoes just as it’s true of cupcakes, pizza, and any other food—healthy or unhealthy—that you could name. OK, I admit this article’s [...]

Read the full article →

Are you giving your scale too much power?

March 19, 2013
Thumbnail image for Are you giving your scale too much power?

How do you feel about the numbers you see on your bathroom scale? This is a loaded question, of course: I’m asking what emotional response you have to an objective fact, the amount you weigh at any given moment. I started thinking about this question after reading a fitness columnist’s exhortation not to [...]

Read the full article →

Kick metabolic syndrome to the curb with strength training

March 11, 2013
strength training protects against metabolic syndrome

Color me shocked: A recently published study, conducted with data gathered between 1999 and 2004, found that only about 6.3 percent of U.S. women over 20 reported lifting weights regularly. I don’t have any illusions about the prevalence of couch-potatoism. But because I’m talking about fitness all the time and hanging out in [...]

Read the full article →

Are you up for my free fat loss and fitness challenge?

March 11, 2013
Thumbnail image for Are you up for my free fat loss and fitness challenge?

One-sixth of 2013 is already gone. Hard to believe, isn’t it? Now, I don’t know whether you’re feeling pleased or frustrated (or both) with the first two months of the year. But I have a challenge for you if you want to make the next six weeks truly memorable. On Dec. 2 I [...]

Read the full article →
Google Analytics Alternative